Would a Federal Reserve Rate Cut Bring Down Inflation and the Cost of Insurance?
As the Federal Reserve cuts interest rates, many Americans wonder if relief from soaring insurance premiums is finally on the horizon. The answer is more complicated than you might expect.
The Fed's Recent Actions
Since September 2024, The Federal Reserve has reduced its benchmark rate by 1 percentage point, reducing rates three consecutive times to a range of 4.25% to 4.5%. This marks a significant shift from the aggressive rate hikes of 2022-2023, when the Fed pushed rates to their highest level in over two decades to combat inflation.
Although inflation has declined from its peak levels, the Fed now projects inflation could be higher in 2025 at 2.5%, with expectations of only two additional rate cuts next year.
Why Insurance Costs Keep Rising
Despite cooling inflation, insurance premiums continue climbing. Car insurance has jumped nearly 13% over the past year, health insurance climbed almost 6%, and household and tenant insurance crept up 2%.
Several factors explain this disconnect:
The Catch-Up Effect: Insurers must demonstrate to state regulators that their costs have increased before they're allowed to raise prices, meaning they're now playing catch-up after years of rising repair and replacement costs.
Rising Repair Costs: In 2022, the cost of parts for automakers increased by 10%, while aftermarket prices paid by consumers increased by 17%, with vehicle parts continuing to rise over 8% in 2023. Modern vehicles with complex technology are simply more expensive to repair.
Climate Change Impact: The planet warming has resulted in more severe hurricanes and fires, creating much larger insurance losses than in the past, particularly affecting states like California and Florida.
Legal Costs: Legal system abuse, including third-party litigation funding that has become a multibillion-dollar global asset class, is proliferating insurance cost increases.
The Interest Rate Paradox
Here's the counterintuitive part: lower interest rates may not help—and could even hurt—insurance affordability.
Insurance companies invest premium dollars in income-generating accounts, with returns on these investments potentially lowering the total amount customers must pay in premiums. When rates are higher, insurers earn more on investments, which can offset underwriting losses. When the Fed cuts rates, these investment returns decline, potentially forcing insurers to raise premiums to maintain profitability.
Conclusion
Federal Reserve rate cuts alone won't solve the insurance affordability crisis. Even with general inflation cooling, factors like complex vehicle technology and climate change risk are keeping insurance costs high.
The forces driving insurance costs—climate risk, vehicle complexity, legal system issues, and supply chain disruptions—operate independently of monetary policy. While Fed rate cuts help the broader economy, your insurance bill is determined by factors the central bank simply cannot control.
Rather than waiting for economic conditions to change, take control of your insurance costs now. We help clients navigate the complexities of today's market through comprehensive comparisons, policy bundling opportunities, and regular coverage reviews. We leverage our carrier relationships to ensure our clients don't have gaps in coverage while identifying options that fit your budget and protection needs.
Personal Lines Application
At Engage Insurance, we protect what matters most to you. Our personal lines division offers tailored coverage for your home, auto, valuables, and more. We work with multiple carriers to design protection that fits your lifestyle and budget—ensuring you have the right coverage without paying for what you don't need.
Commercial Lines
Business owners face evolving risks. Our commercial lines team protects businesses of all sizes with comprehensive coverage: general liability, professional liability, property, workers' comp, cyber liability, bonding, and more. We understand industry-specific risks and craft policies that protect your business's continuity and reputation.
Life Insurance
Life insurance secures your family's future and creates lasting legacies. We offer term, whole, universal, and indexed universal life policies. Our advisors help you find the right balance between protection and investment—coverage that evolves with your changing needs and financial goals.